Hawks Nightly
More
The Peachtree Report · The big question

The Big Question: Is the McCollum Five a Contender's Core or a Short Window?

Atlanta's best group buried teams last season. Age, shooting and a tight payroll decide how far it goes.

+20.3Core five margin391 minutes together last season
-11.8Final-ten slidePer game, versus plus-1.1 overall
18.8Daniels from deepThree-point percentage last season
$198.5MPayrollTax line sits at $200.4M
By the Hawks Nightly Desk · Friday, October 23

Atlanta's season comes down to whether the McCollum, Alexander-Walker, Okongwu, Johnson and Daniels group can carry 82 games and then a series against New York. Over the regular season it can, but the bench and the books still have to raise its ceiling.

Hawks Nightly artwork
Illustration by Hoops Nightly.

The case for the five

That group played 391 minutes across 30 games last season and finished plus-20.3, scoring 123.1 and giving up 102.8. The parts back it up. Jalen Johnson made All-NBA Third Team at 22.5 points, 10.3 rebounds and 7.9 assists. Nickeil Alexander-Walker won Most Improved Player at 20.8 points on 39.9 percent from deep, and ESPN credited him with 31 in Wednesday's 132-125 win at Orlando. CJ McCollum added 18.7 a night after arriving in the Trae Young trade with Washington. Onyeka Okongwu and Dyson Daniels anchor a defense that ranked ninth.

The case against it

Over its final ten games last season, this team was outscored by 11.8 a night after sitting at plus-1.1 for the year. McCollum is 35. Daniels hit 18.8 percent from three, which lets defenses sag off him and crowd Johnson. In the six-game loss to the Knicks, the center rotation ran thin and neither Johnson nor Alexander-Walker scored enough in the defeats. The frontcourt is already short again. Henri Veesaar's torn ACL ends his year, and Mouhamed Gueye's left foot keeps him sidelined until an estimated Nov. 20.

The books set the ceiling

Payroll is $198.5M against a $200.4M tax line, which leaves less than $2M of room. The 2027 first belongs to San Antonio and the 2028 first is a swap, so the trade chips are thin. Luguentz Dort's $18.2M deal carries a team option, which gives the front office some flexibility but won't buy a star. The verdict: yes, this is a contender's core for the regular season, good enough to keep Atlanta near the top of the conference, where it sits third at 1-0. Beating New York in the spring is a different question. That depends on Quin Snyder finding a sixth scorer among Aaron Wiggins, Corey Kispert, Jock Landale and Kingston Flemings, because the front office has almost nothing left to buy one with.

What is the Hawks' best lineup?

It's CJ McCollum, Nickeil Alexander-Walker, Onyeka Okongwu, Jalen Johnson and Dyson Daniels. That five outscored opponents by 20.3 per 100 possessions over 391 minutes last season.

Are the Hawks over the luxury tax in 2026-27?

No. Atlanta's payroll is $198.5M, which puts it over the cap but under the $200.4M tax line.

By the Hawks Nightly Desk, written from the club's data and the reports on file, with every name and number checked against them. How the desks work.

More from The Peachtree Report

all Hawks news →