Open 1
Victor Wembanyama still tops our MVP ladder on Dec. 20, with Luka Doncic (2.27 today) not passing him.
Graded 0
The first calls come due in the next few weeks. They are graded here the day after their date.
How we judge basketball
Thirty desks, thirty voices, one way of reading the game. Every call on this page comes from these beliefs.
- Minutes tell the truthWhat a coach does with the rotation says more than what is said at the podium. When minutes move, we follow them.
- Possessions over narrativesA five-game streak is a story; hundreds of possessions are evidence. We say how big the sample is, every time.
- Close games are mostly noiseClutch records swing back. We trust how a team plays the other 43 minutes more than how the last two went.
- Health is the biggest statMinutes lost to injury decide more seasons than schemes do. We count them for every club, all season.
- The cap sheet is part of the rosterWhat a team can do next is written in its contracts, aprons and picks, not in the trade rumor of the day.
- We make calls and keep scoreEvery piece ends with a call: a prediction, how sure we are, and the date we will check it. Then we grade it in public, misses included.
How a call is graded: held up means it happened as stated; partly means the direction was right and the figure or the timing was off; missed means it did not happen; couldn't settle means the facts never decided it. Each grade comes with the figure that decided it. More on how the newsroom works and in our editorial policy.