On October 9, the Knicks froze every extension conversation touching Karl-Anthony Towns, and he called it disappointing. New York carries $227.7 million in payroll, above the second apron, with Towns the first name on a depth chart that still runs through James Wiseman, Tony Bradley and Andre Drummond.
The Freeze
Ownership shut down extension talks on October 9. Josh Hart addressed the decision the next day, October 10, without saying where it leaves the roster. Towns spoke for himself on October 11 — the New York Post reported he called it 'News to me.' ESPN reported he called the move disappointing. Carmelo Anthony, also speaking to ESPN, said the Knicks were right to pause talks and focus on the season.
The Money Case
Towns is owed $57.1 million this season, the largest number on a $227.7 million payroll that already sits above the second apron. Anunoby ($42.5 million), Brunson ($37.7 million) and Bridges ($33.5 million) make up the rest of the top four. A new extension stacks on top of that figure, and the apron already limits the trade exceptions and roster moves a team uses to fix a mistake. New York also owes its 2027 and 2029 first-round picks to Brooklyn, with little margin left to spend its way out of a wrong bet.
Centers Waiting
The position behind Towns is not empty. James Wiseman, Tony Bradley and Andre Drummond are all on the roster, and an early-October note grouped all four under one position without saying who starts if Towns walks. None of the three touched Towns' numbers from last season — 20.1 points and 11.9 rebounds across 75 starts on a 53-win team that went on to win the title.
Both Sides
The case against paying: Towns turns 31 this season, the deal would push an already-taxed payroll further past the apron, and the front office has now shown it is willing to walk away from the table. The case for paying: he started 75 games for a championship team, and an offense built around Brunson needs a center who can score and rebound at that level. Nobody behind him on this roster does both.
Decision Coming
The freeze is not a no. It is New York buying time to weigh cost against need before it has to decide. Towns is still the best center on this roster, and no extension gets signed until the Knicks decide they can afford to say yes.
Why did the Knicks pause Karl-Anthony Towns' extension talks?
New York announced the freeze on October 9 without detailing a reason, and Towns said the move surprised him, calling it disappointing.
Who plays center for the Knicks if Towns leaves?
James Wiseman, Tony Bradley and Andre Drummond are the centers on the roster behind him, but none matched his 20.1 points and 11.9 rebounds from last season.
More from The Garden Line
all Knicks news →
From the archives · Wed, Oct 14The Garden Built Winners Long Before This Loss
Morning · Wed, Oct 14Knicks' Reserves Get Buried In Toronto
The big question · Wed, Oct 7Knicks Face A Bill They Can't Pay Twice
The big question · Sun, Oct 4The Bill Comes Due For New York's Champions
The big question · Thu, Oct 1Knicks Bet Everything On One More Run
The big question · Mon, Sep 28Knicks Chase A Repeat While Two Contracts Hang Fire